Primal Bound

What loneliness does to your brain (and how to undo it)

Being cut off from people shows up in survival numbers. In 2010, a review of 148 studies following 308,849 people found that those with stronger social ties had a 50% greater chance of surviving the years they were followed. The authors called the size of that effect comparable to quitting smoking. That review measured ties, not the feeling of loneliness. But the feeling starts in the brain, and one trial found a fix that took about ten minutes a call.

A quiet phone at nine on a Sunday

Nothing has hurt you. Nobody was cruel. The phone has not lit up since morning, and your chest is tight anyway. Why would a brain treat a quiet phone like that?

The world the alarm was built for

In 2011, anthropologists counted who lived with whom in 32 foraging societies, more than 5,000 people. A band held brothers, sisters, in-laws, and people who were no relation at all. For almost all of human history, an evening meant a fire with other people around it.

Now the American Time Use Survey. Kannan and Veazie analysed 219,368 respondents from 2003 to 2020. Time spent in person with friends fell from about 60 minutes a day in 2003 to 34 in 2019, and to 20 in 2020, the pandemic year. Time alone rose from 285 minutes a day to 333, about 48 minutes more.

What being left out does inside the head

In 2003, Naomi Eisenberger and colleagues at UCLA put 13 students in a brain scanner and had them play a ball-tossing game with two other players. Then the other two stopped throwing to them. The anterior cingulate cortex, a region also seen in studies of physical pain, was more active during exclusion, and the more active it was, the more distress the student reported. Thirteen people is a very small study, so hold it loosely.

In 2014, Woo and colleagues scanned 60 people who felt painful heat and looked at photos of ex-partners. Rejection and pain activated the same broad area, but they left different patterns, and a classifier trained on one performed at chance on the other. So rejection appears to run its own alarm, wired close to the pain system rather than sharing it.

The alarm changes what you watch

In 2009, John Cacioppo's team scanned 23 young women while they looked at pictures. In the lonelier women, the ventral striatum, a reward area, responded less to pleasant pictures of people. Their visual cortex responded more to unpleasant pictures of people, like conflict. Less pleasure in happy people, and more attention to trouble. Another small study, but it points at the thing a fix has to reach.

An old guard on a new watch

Cacioppo's theory, set out with Louise Hawkley in 2009, is that for most of human history, being pushed to the edge of the band was dangerous. A brain that hurt when it was left out, and searched for threat, kept people close to the fire. That is a theory, not a measured result. What was measured is that lonely people tend to form more negative impressions of others and to be less charitable about their intentions.

On that account the feeling is not a fault in you. It is an old guard, still on watch, in a world with 34 minutes a day of friends.

What the trials found

In 2011, Masi, Chen, Hawkley and Cacioppo pooled the trials that tried to reduce loneliness and sorted them into four kinds: improving social skills, enhancing social support, increasing opportunities for contact, and addressing maladaptive social cognition, meaning how lonely people read others. Across 20 randomized comparisons the effect was small but significant. The kind that worked best was the last one. More company, on its own, did less.

The ten-minute trial

In 2020, Maninder Kahlon's team in Texas enrolled 240 adults who received Meals on Wheels, 120 in each arm. Half got phone calls from 16 callers aged 17 to 23, trained for an hour in one skill: listen, and ask about the topics the other person raises. Calls were meant to run under ten minutes. Everyone called got five calls in the first week, then chose two to five a week, for four weeks.

On the UCLA loneliness scale, the called group fell from 6.5 to 5.2. The group not called went from 6.5 to 6.3. The difference was 1.1 points (Cohen's d 0.48). Depression and anxiety also fell.

Read the limits. It lasted four weeks, people rated themselves, and more of the called group dropped out (13 against 1). It eased the feeling; nobody scanned a brain.

The fix, as it was tested

  1. Short calls. Under ten minutes, not an evening.
  2. Often. Five in the first week, then two to five a week.
  3. Listen and ask. The callers' job was to ask about what the other person brought up, not to perform.
  4. Four weeks. That is how long anyone measured.

In the trial the calls came in, not out, so making them yourself is one step past the evidence. And in Masi's review, what worked best changed how lonely people read others, so a slow reply that feels like rejection may be the old guard, reading it.

Sources

  1. Holt-Lunstad, Smith and Layton (2010), Social relationships and mortality risk: a meta-analytic review, PLOS Medicine. journal
  2. Hill et al. (2011), Co-residence patterns in hunter-gatherer societies show unique human social structure, Science. ASU summary
  3. Kannan and Veazie (2023), US trends in social isolation, social engagement, and companionship, SSM Population Health. pmc
  4. Eisenberger, Lieberman and Williams (2003), Does rejection hurt? An fMRI study of social exclusion, Science. pubmed
  5. Woo et al. (2014), Separate neural representations for physical pain and social rejection, Nature Communications. pmc
  6. Cacioppo, Norris, Decety, Monteleone and Nusbaum (2009), Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience; findings as reported in Cacioppo and Hawkley (2009), Perceived social isolation and cognition, Trends in Cognitive Sciences. pmc · UChicago news
  7. Masi, Chen, Hawkley and Cacioppo (2011), A meta-analysis of interventions to reduce loneliness, Personality and Social Psychology Review. pmc · UChicago Medicine
  8. Kahlon et al. (2021), Effect of layperson-delivered, empathy-focused program of telephone calls on loneliness, depression, and anxiety among adults during the COVID-19 pandemic, JAMA Psychiatry. journal

This article reports what these studies measured. It is not medical advice. If loneliness is weighing on you, talk to a doctor or a counsellor.

Film version, with the sources on screen: What Loneliness Does to Your Brain (and How to Undo It) (4:59).